Friday, 14 September 2012

Air Combat Bibliography

To support some of the game ideas and developments as well as providing me with some new scenario ideas, I thought it would be useful to provide my current library details. Not so much as showing off but so you can understand my reasoning and references later on.

Operations over Vietnam

  • Dorr, Robert F. Air War Hanoi (Chichester: Guild Publishing, 1988).
  • Michel III, Marshall L. Clashes: Air Combat over North Vietnam 1965 - 1972 (Annapolis: Naval Institute Press, 1997).
  • Hobson, Chris. Vietnam Air Losses: United States Airforce, Navy and Marine Corps Fixed-Wing Aircraft Losses in SEA 1961-1973 (Hinckley: Midland Publishing, 2001).
  • Nicols, John B. and Tillman, Barrett. On Yankee Station: Naval Air War Over Vietnam (Airlife Publishing Ltd, 1997).
  • Ethell, Jeffrey. and Price, Alfred. One Day in A Long War - May 10, 1972 Air War, North Vietnam (New York: Random House, 1989).

Specific Aircraft Histories over Vietnam

  • Elward, B and Davies P. US Navy F-4 Phantom II MiG Killers 1965-70 (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2001).
  • Elward, B and Davies P. US Navy F-4 Phantom II MiG Killers 1972-73 (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2002).
  • Powell, Robert R. RA-5C Vigilante Units in Combat (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2004).
  • Burgess, Richard R. and Rausa, Rosario M. US Navy A-1 Skyraider Units of the Vietnam War (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2009).
  • Toperczer, Istvan. MiG-17 and MiG-19 Units of the Vietnam War (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2001).
  • Mersky, Peter. F-8 Crusader Units of the Vietnam War (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 1998).
  • Birzer, Norman and Mersky, Peter. US Navy A-7 Corsair II Units of the Vietnam War (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2004).
  • Mersky, Peter. US Navy and Marine Corps A-4 Skyhawk Units of the Vietnam War (Oxford: Osprey Publishing, 2007).
Iran-Iraq Conflict



  • Cooper, Tom and Bishop, Farzad. Iran-Iraq War in the Air 1980 - 1988 (Atglen: Schiffer Military History, 2000).

General Air Combat

  • Spick, Mike. Modern Fighter Combat (London: Salamander Books Ltd, 1987).

Downtown - 10 May 1972 Variant Forces

While researching the Colours game I started looking at "real" mission compositions.  These are the two constructed from the notes and tables in "One Day in a Long War"

Haiphong POL Strike
Pre Raid Forces
JAMMING MISSION

  • 1 x {1} [EKA-3B], Jamming
Main Raid Forces
Iron Hand Mission

  • 2 x {1} [A-7E], SEAD (Each flight has 2 x Shrike & CBU and has 1 AIM-9)

MiGCAP Mission

  • 4 x {2} [F-4J], CAP
STRIKE Mission

  • 2 x {3} [A-6A], Bombing
  • 2 x {3} [A-7E], Bombing
  • 1 x {4} [A-7E], Bombing
  • 2 x {2} [F-4J], Armed Escort

Post Raid Forces
RECON Mission

  • 1 x {1} [RA-5C], Recon
  • 1 x {1} [F-4J], CAP
Hai Duong Bridge Mission
Pre Raid Forces
JAMMING MISSION

  • 1 x {1} [EKA-3B], Jamming
Main Raid Forces
Iron Hand Mission

  • 2 x {1} [A-7E], SEAD (Each flight has 2 x Shrike & CBU)
  • 2 x {1} [F-4J], Armed Escort
MiGCAP Mission

  • 3 x {2} [F-4J], CAP
STRIKE Mission

  • 2 x {3} [A-6A], Bombing
  • 2 x {3} [A-7E], Bombing
  • 1 x {4} [A-7E], Bombing
  • 2 x {2} [F-4J], Armed Escort (Top Gun)

Post Raid Forces
RECON Mission

  • 1 x {1} [RA-5C], Recon
  • 1 x {1} [F-4J], CAP

1/600th Aircraft - Korea - USAF/USN

Korea air combat is what started me off in 1/600th. Our first outing with Check Your 6 Jet Age, was a traditional MiG vs Sabre get up. With the Air War Korea Scenario book on order from Caliver Books I've been back to look at some of my earlier models.

This one is the F9F of Lt Cmdr Tom Amen who was the CO of VF-111 but in the Amen Scenario was flying 209 loaned from VF-112



Help for some of my 1/600th cousins out there on decals for the Air War Korea book. First up are the Sabres (yes cheesey but it is what grabbed my interest in the period in the first place).
I tried lots of different methods the main problem I had was finding a decent yellow which would cover. I failed so went back to home made decals.
These have white decal paper markings which means the colour shows through. Very simple straight bar shape which you cut to fit for the wing edges, the mould lines are off so I tried a couple of versions. The fuselage stripes again are simple "L" shapes which wrap around, trimmed to fit.
These are still slightly over scale and because of the thickness of the tail I haven't done the Buzz numbers yet.
The tail is in scale so the getting the checkerboard to fit was fine. The U.S. AIRFORCE and BuNo are on the decal itself
The white striped one has that as a small decal and the rudder strip again as a single thin black line decal.
90% Complete, need to do the canopies and varnish.
Oooops nearly forgot, I have gone to different painting regime as well. Undercoat is GW Chainmail. Then highlight with GW Mithril silver. My early try outs were just too dark.

Early F-86A in the 4FIW scheme.


  The rest will be the 51 FIW scheme






Thursday, 13 September 2012

WWII - 1940 - Eagle Run through

From the reviews on BGG it appears that playing RAF Battle of Britain 1940 is best played as either Eagle (Luftwaffe Solo) or 2 Player H2H. Not having an opponent, yet, These are the write ups from Playing EAGLE. I have Vassal which means that I can take this on the road with me and keep things ticking over. LION is the RAF Solo version which does appear to be mainly a responsive game and I wanted the ability to plan raids. So Eagle it is in which will hopefully generate some Scenarios for CY6.

PRELUDE TO EAGLE
This is the introductory scenario to get to grips with the game. It covers just prior to 13 August 1940.


Setting Up for Play I confused myself for a couple of minutes sorting out the decks until I realised that all the cards are numbered and not just ones in the particular groups. It would also be useful if you were told not to use the Force Cards as I spent time looking for the rules on how these are used and couldn't find them. They are for LION only.

So you only need:
Target Cards 01 - 34
Raid Event Cards 91 - 131
Reminder to set aside cards for Prelude To Eagle ONLY
35 - 60
61 - 90
132 - 134
135 - 154
155 - 164
Daily Planning Phase After shuffling the cards, I drew 10 Target cards.

  • 4 are NO RAID due to the current strategy rating
  • Luftflotte 3 has an easy day as has no raids assigned to it.
  • Bad news for Luftflotte 2 (no idea if it is or isn't I have no concept for how ovestretched this will be for LF2):
    • Major Raid against the Port of Dover
    • Major Raid against Biggin Hill Airfield
    • Major Raid against Hornchurch Airfield
    • Major Raid against Kenley Airfield
    • Major Raid against Beachy Head RDF Station
    • Minor Raid against Hornchurch Airfield
It would appear from the rules that as this is a campaign system I don't have to launch a raid against every target but can choose. The less targets I choose the easier it is to protect with Fighters (assumption on my part). However as this is a simple Scenario the VPs are harder to look at but the idea of the scenario is to introduce the player to the game and not necessarily achieve a win.

As this is an introductory session I am only going to fly two missions to check how the mechanics work and then come back and playout this again (using same targets but different compositions etc). Me-109 only Freie Jagd sweep to strafe Kenley Airfield and then a bomb run against the Radar at Beachy Head using the Ju-87s!

Raid 1
5 Me-109 Gruppen, 3 in HB, 1 in CE, 1 in BB

Raid 2
3 Me-109 in HB
2 Me-109 in CE
2 Ju-87 in BB

Weather for the Day is: 3 = Patchy Cloud
I have the following to choose from:

  • 2 Ju-87
  • 2 Ju-88
  • 8 He-111
  • 9 Do-17Z
  • 7 Me-110
  • 15 Me-109

6 possible raids allows me to split this into 2 time slots BUT it means that I would only have 5 Me-109 supporting each raid. This is probably a bit tight and I couldn't afford a loss. SO this means probably not having more than 2 raids per time slot and then see if I can recycle the fighters. Keeping the bombers intact does seem easier though as they can only fly once per day.
Raid Phase - Raid 1 British Detection (5)

+4 for OCV, +4 for Radar, +2 Gruppen, -2 Me-109 Total + 1d6 = 13 Early Warning, Poor Intelligence. Minor Raid
Rendevouz Check (4)

Passed
Raid Response (2)

13 Squadrons available for response however only turns into 12 counters (no 2nd for 3/11)

1

32

56

111

501

601

615

43(S)

64(S)

65(S)

75(S)

234(S)


+1 11 Gp, +2 Airfield, +1d6 = 5 Minimal 7 Squadrons. I return 5 squadrons (at random) to their sectors (crossed out above). Because I declared this a Minor Raid from those left the British only send 3 squadrons to intercept (not good for the RAF, assumption), If I had declared it to a major raid then 6 would have intercepted which would, I asssume, have been harder)

I end up facing the following RAF Squadrons 1, 43(S) & 64(S)

NOTE: Completely messed up. REMOVE using the response priority chart. Doh! Raid 1 should have been remove 7 not take 7. So this would have been worse and only 2 squadrons to start with. However, I forgot that there were two raids this would have been 4 on the response which would have been High priority with -5 so the end result would have been that as follows.
Hunter Interception

3 Squadrons vs 3 Gruppen = stay in the HB.
Raid Approach Event

British Altitude Advantage - No conditions apply ignore
Hunter Attack (2)

3*0 + 2*4 + 1*3 = 11 Column E Rolling 1d6 = -LD ALD

1 Gruppe to CE

1 Gruppe to LL (+1 VP)

1 Gruppe Inflight

2 Sqn to LL (-2 VP)

1 Sqn to inflight (F)
Raid Target Event

Late Interception - Ignore as Early Warning Received
Squadron Interception

N/A no Squadrons. The CE Gruppe moves to BB. The HB Gruppe which moved to CE now moves to BB
Squadron Attack

N/A no Squadrons
Bombardment

3*1 = 3 Bomb points. Move 2 columns right as no Sqns in the BB 1D6 = 5 (-2 VP)

111 & 615 Sqns disperse to Land Box (and would have lost 2 replacement points)

All Gruppe to Inflight

German Recovery

All Me-109 move to Re-Arm
Clock Check

Raid Still Open start Raid 2





















In terms of scenario generation not too sure what to do here. 2 Possible scenarios have been generated:

We have 1 Hurricane and 2 Spitfire Squadrons up against 3 Gruppe in a straight fight which didn't go well for the RAF so the CY6 victory conditions should follow that.

Second Scenario would have a ground attack scenario which sees 3 Gruppe shooting up Kenley Airfield. I don't have CY6 so don't know what do here (yet).



Need to chat this with the Yahoo group.
Raid Phase - Raid 2 British Detection (6)

+1 for OCV, +4 for Radar, +3 Gruppen, Total + 1d6 = 14 Sufficient Warning, Accurate Intelligence.
Rendevouz Check (5)

Passed
Raid Response (1)

9 Squadrons possibly assigned however there are only 5 squadrons in the pool due to raid 1.

32

145

501

601

74(S)

+1 11 Gp, +2 Radar, +2 Accurate & at least 1 Gruppe +1d6 = Low, -2 Squadrons.

3 Squadrons check against Accurate Intelligence with Bomber Gruppen = Yes all respond
Hunter Interception

3 Squadrons vs 3 Gruppen = stay in the HB.
Raid Approach Event

British Altitude Advantage - No conditions apply ignore
Hunter Attack (3)

3*0 + 2*3 + 1*4 = 10 Column D rolling 1D6 DDA DAL
Raid Target Event

Non essential Target, reduce bomb damage. Aargh Damage does not affect RADAR but at least any VP will go towards the total.
Squadron Interception

The spitfire intercepts one of the Ju-87s. The other Ju-87 and one CE Me-109 are not intercepted. This leaves the other CE Me-109 to be included in the combat.
Squadron Attack (3)

1*0 + 1*7 + 1*2 = 9 Column E rolling 1D6 DAA -AL

1 Ju-87 Reduced stay in BB

1 Me-109 Inflight Reduced

Spitfire to LL (-1 VP)
Bombardment (5)

1*2 + 1*3 = 5 move 1 column left due to Patchy Cloud

-1 VP only due to the Raid Card
German Recovery

Every one goes home for the day
Clock Check

Clock moves on as there are no more raids planned
Need to re-read the combat damage charts as it appears that I misinterpreted this for Raid 1. The disrupted Spitfire Squadron makes it through to the Bomber Box albeit in reduced state



In terms of scenarios, This would have a small Spitfire contingent trying to get into the Ju-87s. Probably look at something requiring a jettison check as opposed to a shoot down as the RAF will be up against it.

More work needed
Airfield OperationsNot being used for the introductory scenario
Calendar UpdateNot being used for the introductory scenario

Overall this took the best part of evening to play as I used the VASSAL module as I was away from home. Definitely something that can be toted around to fill in the odd hours. A Word document to keep the narrative is easy to maintain. Upshot would be that the RAF are at -4 VP from just the two raids. I think the RAF were unlucky on the raid against Kenley to which disrupted the defences and peeled back the defenders against the second raid or is this my good planning (NOT!). Having just a couple of squadrons I think would have caused problems for the Ju-87 raid. A lot more needs to be played out but the mechanics are slick and the charts flow well which is good. First time I have used this particular VASSAL module which isn't necessary good for learning as the interface had to be learnt as well, but the guy who coded this gets a big thumbs up it definately made my life easier working out where things went. In Flight is an area that I want to look at again.

In terms of CY6 Scenario generation very useful tool and possibly some interesting things to be come out of it. Goes against my sensibilities though letting the Luftwaffe shoot up the airfields! but a problem facing most wargamers someone is always the bad guys.... More to follow (as usual)